Italy has fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million over a Facebook Android feature that recommended pictures from users' phone galleries. The privacy regulator says a broad app permission and a default-on suggestion setting did not amount to informed consent for that particular use. Its order requires a separate opt-in, but the finding should not be confused with proof that entire photo libraries were copied or used to train artificial intelligence.

What Italy's privacy regulator found

Italy's data-protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, announced an €805 million penalty against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited on November 14, 2026. The regulator said Facebook's Android application had accessed photographs, videos and associated metadata stored in users' phone galleries without a sufficiently specific request for consent or adequate explanation. It estimated that about 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. That figure is an estimate of users involved in the practice, not a verified count of individual galleries searched or photographs inspected.

Reuters reported the sanction at approximately $887 million, using the exchange rate available when its report was published. The euro figure is the amount imposed by the Italian authority. The Garante also said the penalty equalled roughly 0.47% of Meta's global group revenue. This was an action by Italy's privacy regulator, not an antitrust fine from the country's competition authority.

The decision addresses the conditions under which an application could obtain access to information stored on a personal device. It does not establish that Facebook copied every photograph, published private images or transferred entire galleries to company servers. Those different allegations would require evidence not supplied by the regulator's announcement.

Sources: Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro · Italy fines Meta $887 million over Android users' data access

How a broad phone permission became a separate consent problem

The feature at the centre of the case was presented as 'Get suggestions from your gallery when you browse Facebook'. Available since 2023, it could suggest photos and videos from a user's phone gallery as material for a possible Facebook post. The Garante found that Facebook requested a single authorization covering different functions throughout the Android app, accompanied by a general notice about enabling additional features.

That design created a gap between a technical permission and a clear choice about a particular service. Someone allowing an app to find a picture for an intentional upload has not necessarily agreed to continuing suggestions drawn from the wider gallery. According to the authority, the suggestions feature was enabled by default and the general permission did not make its separate purpose clear.

A fully granted permission could allow the application to read the device's full photographic archive, ordinarily on a continuing basis, the Garante said. Crucially, the authority added that neither the user nor the regulator could verify precisely which information was actually used. Capability, access and proven onward handling are not interchangeable. The finding should not be stretched into a claim that each of the estimated 20 million users had every image collected.

Sources: Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro

The legal basis was ePrivacy, not an antitrust ruling

The Garante identified Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the European ePrivacy framework, as the rule breached. In the authority's explanation, accessing information held on a smartphone requires free and informed consent. The protection is not conditional on proving that information later left the device or that an individual suffered a measurable loss. The device itself is treated as part of a person's private sphere.

Meta contested the Italian regulator's competence and argued in favour of oversight by the Irish authority. The Garante rejected that objection on the basis that the ePrivacy rules at issue do not use the GDPR's one-stop-shop supervisory mechanism. This explains why the dispute concerns Italian enforcement jurisdiction, but it is not a blanket finding that every Meta activity across Europe falls under the same Italian procedure.

The investigation began in July 2025 after a report from the consumer-protection centre in Bolzano. The Italian authority says it carried out technical analysis of the feature. Its announcement also cites the duration of the infringement, an earlier 2019 measure and what it considered insufficient cooperation when explaining the penalty; changes introduced after the report were treated as mitigating but late and limited.

Sources: Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro

What Meta must do—and what has not happened yet

Under the announced order, Meta has 60 days to obtain distinct, specific consent for the gallery-suggestions function. Users must be told what the feature does, that it involves access to their phone gallery and how it can be disabled. The function must remain switched off by default, including for people who previously granted a broad app permission. If compliant consent is absent after the deadline, it must not be activated for the relevant users.

The authority also instructed Meta to report the initiatives it had started within 30 days and the measures it adopted within 90 days. Those are separate reporting requirements, not three different dates by which the feature may remain enabled. The press release does not by itself verify that all changes have already been implemented, nor does it establish what will happen in any later appeal.

Reuters said Meta was not immediately available for comment when its November 14 report was filed. That is a reporting-status statement, not a formal reply from the company to the decision. An updated company response, compliance report or court development would need a separately dated source before it could change the account given here.

Sources: Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro · Italy fines Meta $887 million over Android users' data access

AI training and cloud processing are separate questions

The Garante expressly said the proceeding did not investigate whether photographs or videos from the gallery-suggestion feature had been used to train artificial-intelligence models. The announcement records that Meta denied such use. Neither statement amounts to a regulatory finding that training took place; nor is Meta's denial an independently verified technical audit.

The regulator separately reserved the right to assess a newer function launched in 2026 that allows gallery material to be processed in the cloud. That possible future assessment is not part of the €805 million sanction. The difference matters because access to information on a device, cloud processing and AI-model training involve different technical practices and different evidentiary questions.

For the same reason, the fine cannot responsibly be described as punishment for using people's private photos to train AI. The verified legal dispute is about consent for a Facebook Android gallery-suggestions feature. Readers should not have to infer a more sensational allegation from the size of the penalty.

Sources: Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro · Italy fines Meta $887 million over Android users' data access

What the decision means for users and what to watch next

For Android users, this case illustrates why a phone-level media permission and the settings governing a particular in-app feature deserve separate attention. A broad permission may support several tasks that feel different to the person granting it. The Italian regulator's remedy seeks to make the gallery-suggestion function an explicit choice rather than a default consequence of a more general authorization.

The announcement does not establish a universal set of taps for disabling the feature. Facebook settings can vary with app version and location, and the regulator has described required changes rather than supplying a current step-by-step Android guide. Anyone reviewing their settings should therefore check both the device's app permissions and the options presented inside the app, without assuming either screen alone resolves the consent issue.

Three developments would materially update this story: a documented response or appeal from Meta, verified evidence that the prescribed opt-in and default-off changes have been implemented, and any distinct Garante findings about the newer cloud-processing function. As of the November 14 announcement, none should be treated as an established outcome. The central question remains how clearly an app must ask before repurposing access that users may have granted for another task.

Sources: Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro · Italy fines Meta $887 million over Android users' data access