The International Criminal Court has formally closed its original Afghanistan situation record, but the decision does not end the separate investigation into alleged Taliban crimes since 2021. The ruling also leaves a possible route for a renewed ISIS-K inquiry and is being challenged by the Prosecutor, whose appeal grounds have not been made public.

A formal closure of the original situation record

Judges at the International Criminal Court have closed the original Afghanistan situation record, ending the procedural home for an investigation that covered alleged crimes by Afghan government forces, the Taliban, U.S. troops and U.S. intelligence personnel. The nine-page decision by Pre-Trial Chamber II is dated November 12 and was made public on Friday, November 13. It is registered as ICC-02/17-253-Red.

Closing a record is not the same as deciding the allegations. The Chamber did not rule that crimes never occurred, clear any individual or issue a general judgment on the Court’s jurisdiction. It ordered the Registry to close Situation in Afghanistan, record 02/17. The Taliban-focused inquiry is being pursued in a separate record, Situation in Afghanistan II.

Sources: Public redacted version of ‘Decision closing the situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan’ · Judges close part of ICC Afghanistan investigations that could look at US troops · International Criminal Court limits Afghanistan investigation to Taliban crimes

Why the judges said the original record could not remain open

The Chamber relied on regulation 66ter of the Court’s Regulations, which governs closure of situation records. It requires the Prosecutor to inform the assigned Chamber when the Office decides not to initiate an investigation or no longer anticipates further investigative or prosecutorial activity. The judges said the notification requirement had been met in this case and that they could close the record on their own initiative. The rule also allows reopening if the Prosecutor later decides to initiate or resume an investigation.

The judges said the Prosecution had not shown that it could effectively carry out further work in the original Afghanistan situation. They cited significant limits on its ability to investigate and secure evidence, compounded by the time elapsed since the alleged crimes. The Chamber concluded that leaving the record open would not serve legal certainty, transparency or the proper administration of proceedings.

The Chamber also recorded three lines of inquiry described by the Prosecutor: alleged Taliban crimes against women and girls since August 2021; alleged Taliban crimes against other people since August 2021, including persecution on political, ethnic or religious grounds; and alleged crimes by Islamic State Khorasan Province, or ISIS-K, since 2016.

Sources: Public redacted version of ‘Decision closing the situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan’

The Taliban investigation continues in a separate record

The first two lines of inquiry now belong to Situation in Afghanistan II. The ICC Presidency opened that separate situation on October 20, 2026, and assigned it to Pre-Trial Chamber II. On November 5, the Chamber ordered certain records, including arrest warrants, transferred from the original situation to the new one.

The warrants now sit within the separate situation record. On October 5, the Court made public four warrants issued in 2025 against senior Taliban figures Haibatullah Akhundzada, Abdul Hakim Haqqani, Habibullah Agha and Neda Mohammad Nadim. The allegations concern the crime against humanity of persecution on gender grounds against girls, women and other people who do not conform with Taliban policies on gender, gender identity or expression, and on political grounds against people perceived as allies of girls and women. The warrants are allegations, not convictions.

The November 12 decision expressly says that closing the original record does not preclude the Prosecution’s ongoing investigation in Afghanistan II. The Taliban-focused inquiry therefore continues.

Sources: Public redacted version of ‘Decision closing the situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan’ · Decision assigning the situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan II to Pre-Trial Chamber II · Order to transfer court records to the Situation in Afghanistan II · ICC Pre-Trial Chamber II unseals four arrest warrants in Situation in Afghanistan

What the closure means for ISIS-K and the older U.S. line

The decision also closes the original record in which the Prosecutor had identified an ISIS-K line of inquiry dating back to 2016. But the Chamber did not declare those allegations unfounded or permanently barred. It said that, if the Prosecutor later becomes able to pursue the ISIS-K line effectively, the Office may submit a new application for authorization to investigate, subject to the Rome Statute and the Court’s procedures.

The U.S.-related line has a different history. Reuters reported that the inquiry into alleged crimes by U.S. troops had already been dormant since 2021. The public decision sets out no new investigative plan for those allegations; it closes the broader 02/17 situation. It would be inaccurate to describe this as a factual exoneration of U.S. personnel or a finding that the allegations were disproved.

Sources: Public redacted version of ‘Decision closing the situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan’ · Judges close part of ICC Afghanistan investigations that could look at US troops

A procedural decision, not a ruling on the Court’s reach

The United States is not a party to the Rome Statute and rejects the ICC’s authority over U.S. nationals. But the November 12 decision does not amend the Statute or decide a general question about the Court’s jurisdiction over nationals of non-member states. It addresses whether the Prosecutor had shown an ability to continue work in this particular situation record.

The original investigation was authorized in 2020. The decision describes its scope as alleged crimes on Afghan territory from May 1, 2003, plus certain conflict-related crimes on the territory of other States Parties from July 1, 2002. The legal basis for jurisdiction and the procedural decision to close a record are separate questions; the latter should not be presented as a broad jurisdiction ruling.

Sources: Public redacted version of ‘Decision closing the situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan’ · International Criminal Court limits Afghanistan investigation to Taliban crimes

The Prosecutor says it has appealed; the next step is unclear

The Office of the Prosecutor told Reuters and The Associated Press on November 13 that it had appealed the closure decision. Neither outlet reported the grounds, and the Office provided no further details. The appeal means the decision is being challenged, but it does not yet show whether the Appeals Chamber will suspend, reverse or uphold the closure.

A separate filing in the public docket should not be confused with this reported appeal. On November 11, the Prosecution filed a notice of appeal against the Chamber’s November 5 order transferring records to Afghanistan II. That earlier appeal concerns the transfer order, not the November 12 decision closing the original record.

For now, the position is a closed original record, a continuing Taliban-focused investigation in Afghanistan II, and an ISIS-K line that could return only through a new application if the Prosecutor can pursue it effectively. The reported appeal leaves the immediate procedural outcome unresolved.

Sources: Judges close part of ICC Afghanistan investigations that could look at US troops · International Criminal Court limits Afghanistan investigation to Taliban crimes · Prosecution notice of appeal, and request for suspensive effect, of “Order to transfer court records to the Situation in Afghanistan II” (ICC-02/17-249)