As Southeast Asian leaders prepare to meet in Manila from November 15 to 17, ASEAN faces renewed pressure to reconsider its five-year exclusion of Myanmar’s military-backed leadership from high-level meetings. Thailand is openly calling for a limited opening, while several other members have expanded bilateral contact. But warmer ties with Naypyidaw are not the same as a change in the bloc’s collective position. The summit is expected to review the implementation of ASEAN’s Five-Point Consensus; it has not yet decided to lift the restrictions.

A review is approaching, not a reversal

Since the 2021 coup, Myanmar’s military leadership has been excluded from formal ASEAN summits and formal ministerial meetings because the authorities have not implemented the Five-Point Consensus. Reuters reported on November 13 that leaders are due to review the exclusion at the Manila summit. That review matters, but it is not an announcement that the ban has been lifted or that Myanmar’s military authorities have been readmitted.

Min Aung Hlaing, the coup leader who became president after a military-backed election process, is not expected in Manila. Human Rights Watch said the Philippine government confirmed on November 11 that he would not attend. His absence from this summit does not settle the separate question of who may represent Myanmar at future ASEAN meetings.

Sources: Analysis-ASEAN faces Myanmar dilemma as some members pursue closer ties · ASEAN: Increase Pressure on Myanmar Junta to End Abuses

Bilateral engagement is moving ahead

Reuters reported that nearly half of ASEAN’s 11 members had stepped up bilateral engagement after elections held in December and January. It identified Laos, Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia and Malaysia as countries that had welcomed Min Aung Hlaing on official visits this year. Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim also pledged in October to work toward Myanmar’s reintegration into the bloc.

Reuters described the military-backed Union Solidarity and Development Party as having won overwhelmingly in the elections, in the absence of any viable opposition. Human Rights Watch separately called the polls “sham elections” and urged ASEAN not to recognize or endorse them. That is HRW’s advocacy position, not a characterization that should be presented as an agreed ASEAN finding. The diplomatic fact is that several governments have engaged bilaterally while the bloc’s formal restrictions remain in place.

Sources: Analysis-ASEAN faces Myanmar dilemma as some members pursue closer ties · ASEAN: Increase Pressure on Myanmar Junta to End Abuses

Thailand is pressing for a narrow next step

The clearest public push for easing has come from Bangkok. After visiting Myanmar on November 12, Thai Foreign Minister Sihasak Phuangketkeow said Thailand believed the next step should be allowing Myanmar’s foreign minister to take part in formal ASEAN meetings at foreign-minister level. He said he hoped a decision on Myanmar’s participation could be reached by the time Thailand chairs ASEAN in 2028 at the latest. Thailand had already hosted an informal meeting of ASEAN foreign ministers with Myanmar’s foreign minister on July 12; it did not lift formal restrictions. The November proposal is a further step toward formal participation.

That is a proposed pathway and a timetable, not a decision already made by ASEAN. Reuters reported that Sihasak stressed the decision rested with the bloc’s foreign ministers. Thailand’s interest also has practical dimensions: fighting near its long land border, trade, migrant workers and energy cooperation all affect its relationship with Myanmar. Those concerns help explain Bangkok’s preference for engagement, but do not establish that other members have accepted its proposal.

Sources: Analysis-ASEAN faces Myanmar dilemma as some members pursue closer ties · Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs hosts the Informal Meeting of the ASEAN Foreign Ministers and the Foreign Minister of Myanmar and the Extended Informal Consultation on Myanmar

The Five-Point Consensus remains the common framework

ASEAN’s leaders adopted the Five-Point Consensus on April 24, 2021. Its five elements are an immediate cessation of violence; constructive dialogue among all parties; mediation by a special envoy of the ASEAN chair; humanitarian assistance through the AHA Centre; and a visit by the envoy and delegation to meet all parties. The framework has not been replaced by the recent bilateral contacts.

Philippine foreign ministry spokesperson Dominic Xavier Imperial said leaders would review implementation at the Manila summit and that their decision would be reflected in a negotiated document issued afterward. Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro, ASEAN’s chair’s special envoy on Myanmar, also visited the country on a humanitarian mission in October. Simon Tay, chairman of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs, told Reuters that warmer bilateral ties do not automatically change ASEAN policy. Reuters reported Tay’s view that the consensus would remain unless members collectively agreed otherwise. Tay was directly quoted as saying: “There is room for both good cop and bad cop within ASEAN, provided these different approaches remain within the 5PC framework.” In other words, member states can pursue different diplomatic channels, but those channels do not by themselves rewrite the bloc’s shared position.

Sources: Analysis-ASEAN faces Myanmar dilemma as some members pursue closer ties · ASEAN unity faces test as energy crisis, regional conflicts loom over summit · Chairman’s Statement on the ASEAN Leaders’ Meeting

Rights concerns remain part of the debate

Human Rights Watch is urging ASEAN to maintain the restrictions and increase pressure on Myanmar’s military authorities. In a November 5 letter to Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., it argued that the bloc should not recognize or endorse the elections that led to Min Aung Hlaing’s presidency. Its position is an advocacy demand; the summit’s negotiated outcome remains unknown. Reuters also reported that Aung San Suu Kyi was moved to house arrest in April; a Red Cross official met her in August, but no foreign leader or envoy had been allowed to see her despite requests.

HRW said junta authorities had arrested more than 32,000 people for opposing military rule and that at least 2,300 had reportedly died in custody. These are reported figures cited by the organization, not a precise independent count. Separately, Reuters reported a United Nations estimate that the civil war has killed 100,000 people and displaced more than 3.5 million. HRW also said the International Criminal Court is investigating Min Aung Hlaing; prosecutors requested an arrest warrant in November 2024, but judges had not made a public decision. The International Court of Justice was scheduled to deliver its judgment in the Gambia–Myanmar genocide convention case on November 19, after the summit.

Sources: Analysis-ASEAN faces Myanmar dilemma as some members pursue closer ties · ASEAN unity faces test as energy crisis, regional conflicts loom over summit · ASEAN: Increase Pressure on Myanmar Junta to End Abuses

What Manila can clarify

The immediate test is whether ASEAN can assess the Five-Point Consensus without confusing diplomatic access with political acceptance. The summit can record the state of implementation and signal what members want next. The Philippines has confirmed that a negotiated document will follow, but neither its wording nor any decision to ease the exclusion has been announced.

For now, four points should be kept distinct: bilateral contacts have increased; Thailand has publicly proposed allowing Myanmar’s foreign minister into ministerial-level meetings; the summit will review the consensus and issue an agreed document; and a collective decision on participation remains unresolved. The latest reporting does not establish a vote, a new invitation or a timetable adopted by ASEAN. The question facing Manila is not simply whether to reopen the door, but what progress would justify doing so without making engagement a substitute for the commitments the bloc already set out.

Sources: Analysis-ASEAN faces Myanmar dilemma as some members pursue closer ties · ASEAN unity faces test as energy crisis, regional conflicts loom over summit · ASEAN: Increase Pressure on Myanmar Junta to End Abuses · Chairman’s Statement on the ASEAN Leaders’ Meeting